On the eve of International Women’s Day in 2015, the Chinese government arrested five feminist activists and jailed them for thirty-seven days. The Feminist Five became a global cause célèbre, with Hillary Clinton speaking out on their behalf and activists inundating social media with #FreetheFive messages. But the Five are only symbols of a much larger feminist movement of civil rights lawyers, labor activists, performance artists, and online warriors prompting an unprecedented awakening among China’s educated, urban women. In Betraying Big Brother, journalist and scholar Leta Hong Fincher argues that the popular, broad-based movement poses the greatest challenge to China’s authoritarian regime today.
Through interviews with the Feminist Five and other leading Chinese activists, Hong Fincher illuminates both the difficulties they face and their “joy of betraying Big Brother,” as one of the Feminist Five wrote of the defiance she felt during her detention. Tracing the rise of a new feminist consciousness now finding expression through the #MeToo movement, and describing how the Communist regime has suppressed the history of its own feminist struggles, Betraying Big Brother is a story of how the movement against patriarchy could reconfigure China and the world.
##是本好書。
評分##這是一本值得讀一讀的書,感謝這位作者的發聲
評分##說是中國女權主義的覺醒,然而通篇講來講去就是五姐妹。敘事翻來覆去,重復囉嗦,個人感情色彩太濃,有損閱讀體驗,章節之間關係不強,理論論證站不住腳,精衛填海和鞦瑾的故事聯係太牽強,數據來源也模模糊糊。除瞭五姐妹的采訪,和人民日報的幾篇文章,作者似乎沒有任何其他個人貢獻瞭。
評分##非常極其一般。可以肯定的是記錄瞭近幾年年輕一代特彆是五姐妹的運動細節。但是到瞭介紹曆史背景深入論述的部分,基本就是大型文獻綜述,語言讀起來非常不順,作者自己的知識貢獻很有限
評分##非常失望
評分##某些單方麵決定以評價學術專著的標準來雞蛋裏挑骨頭的用戶,實際上是無事找茬,暴露瞭基於立場和偏見而非基於事實和公正的馬腳
評分##10.6-10.7 好的地方是:梳理記錄瞭2010年之後女權運動的幾個重要人物,她們被抓,被審問,逃亡國外的經過,主要圍繞15年女權5姐妹寫,一直寫到2018年的米兔。還包括瞭人權律師(主要針對女性維權的女律師)的經曆,還寫到勞工運動,女工維權,教育領導勞工維勸的組織;最後也寫到主流流行文化中的女權。不喜歡的地方:膚淺,隻是作為記錄者值得尊敬,作者的分析就不用看瞭。ethnographic approach也有很多弊端,也不是特彆能認同其中寫到的一些人的說法。但總的來說,是非常有意義的一本書,那些在如此黑暗的時代,雖然被迫害,但一直堅持鬥爭的人們,尤其是女性們,她們真的美麗且強大!姐妹們,戰鬥早已經開始瞭!!!
評分##很尷尬的寫法...算紀實感覺作者本人感情過於豐沛,算學術嚮又沒啥分析....敘事也七上八下的,經常蹦一句前不著村後不著店....就是可能在綫索有限的條件下梳理瞭近年社運的題材不容易,給一顆感情星.....
評分##這本書我當作紀錄來看,當作紀念feminist five和新一代feminists 的努力吧。 雖然我並不適很贊同他們中某些人的思路(x